When silver prices soar and market sentiment is high, well-known trader Peter Brandt issues a warning, reminding investors that extreme trading volume does not necessarily indicate demand is out of control; instead, it may imply potential risks of rapidly increasing supply.
(Background recap: Gold and silver plunge for the second time, Bitcoin hits $81,000, with over 270,000 traders suffering liquidation)
(Additional context: Bitcoin is not as good as buying silver! Since 2017, holding returns have been surpassed by silver, and the crypto market crashes: crypto faith loses 8+9)
Table of Contents
- Silver surges with massive volume, Brandt pours cold water
- From the miner’s perspective: high prices mean hedging pressure
- Recycling supply and demand decline, potentially overturning the shortage narrative
As silver prices skyrocket, trading volume explodes, and market sentiment reaches a peak, the renowned trader and analyst Peter Brandt—who successfully predicted the 2018 Bitcoin crash—warns investors: extreme trading volume may not signify demand is out of control; instead, it could indicate a potential rapid increase in supply. His comments quickly sparked heated discussion in the market and added variables to the recent prevalent narrative of a “long-term silver shortage.”
SILVER
SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT
With all the hoopla in Silver, let me suggest something you might not be thinking about. We always need to think “below the surface,” down as many layers as possible.
So far this week Comex has traded 4.3 BILLION ounces of Silver — NOT PAPER…
— Peter Brandt (@PeterLBrandt) January 29, 2026
Silver surges with massive volume, Brandt pours cold water
Recently, Brandt posted on X stating that this week, Comex silver futures traded up to 4.3 billion ounces—equivalent to about 5.2 years of global mine production. As prices hit new highs, many investors see such trading volume as strong evidence of demand.
However, Brandt emphasized that this is not the “paper silver” often downplayed in the market, but real futures contract trading volume. In his view, such figures not only represent demand but may also indicate that a large amount of supply is entering the market.
From the miner’s perspective: high prices mean hedging pressure
Brandt further analyzed from the perspective of mining companies: if silver prices rise to $110 per ounce, this price could be 3 to 4 times their all-in sustaining costs (AISC) for low-cost producers. Under such circumstances, it would be highly irrational for miners not to hedge at least three years of future production.
He pointed out that miners are fundamentally running a business and managing risk, not betting that prices will always go up; locking in profits at high prices is a rational and common decision.
Recycling supply and demand decline, potentially overturning the shortage narrative
Brandt also cited data from the Silver Institute, proposing an alternative scenario that the market might overlook:
Under high prices, the supply of recycled silver could double or even triple; simultaneously, due to excessive prices, industrial users might turn to substitutes, leading to a demand decrease of about 10%.
Under such assumptions, the market could develop a “pipeline glut,” with oversupply replacing the previously discussed “shortage,” rapidly eroding the foundation of the shortage narrative.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Bitmine advances to the NYSE main board! Tom Lee: U.S. stocks may have hit bottom, and selling pressure on Ether could ease
Bitmine has officially moved from the U.S. segment of the New York Stock Exchange to the main board, marking an important milestone for the company. Although its share price has fallen sharply, it has still increased the share repurchase plan limit to $4 billion. The company holds a large amount of Ether, and it expects that a rebound in the crypto market will help improve its assets and share price performance.
CryptoCity1h ago
Bitmine Upgrades to the NYSE Main Board! Tom Lee: US stocks may have bottomed out, and selling pressure on Ether could ease
Bitmine has officially moved from the New York Stock Exchange U.S. board to the main board, marking a major milestone for the company. Despite a sharp drop in the stock price, it has still increased the share repurchase plan to $4.0 billion. The company holds a large amount of Ethereum, and expects that a rebound in the crypto market will help strengthen its assets and stock price performance.
CryptoCity4h ago
RAVE’s hype surge triggers a flood of copycat coin mania, as FF and INX expose the “pump-and-dump” scheme
Recently, altcoins represented by RAVE have sparked a fierce investment craze, but some old star projects like FF and INX have used this wave of hype to carry out “pump-and-dump” operations—rapidly driving up coin prices to lure retail investors to buy, and then dumping them heavily, causing the price to plunge rapidly. Such behavior not only exposes the project team’s funding difficulties, but also damages investors’ trust. Investors need to stay alert to signals like abnormal short-term surges in order to avoid the risk of being manipulated by the market.
MarketWhisper4h ago
Bitmine gets promoted to the NYSE main board! Tom Lee: US stocks may have bottomed out, and sell pressure on Ether could ease
Bitmine has officially moved from the NYSE American board to the main board, marking an important milestone for the company. Despite the sharp decline in its share price, it has still increased the share repurchase plan amount to $4 billion. The company holds a large amount of Ethereum, and it expects that a rebound in the crypto market will help boost its assets and share price performance.
CryptoCity7h ago
Why Is Bitcoin Up Today? Hormuz Blockade Triggers Short Squeeze and a BTC Test of $75k
On April 13, Bitcoin rose from its early-session low of 70,741 to trade as high as $74,900 during the session, approaching the $75,000 level. The main drivers came from two directions: after Trump ordered the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, traders began to view Bitcoin as a geopolitical hedge asset; and a massive net short position that had been building as funding rates stayed persistently negative was met with liquidation, triggering a chain of liquidations totaling millions of dollars near the $70,000 support level.
MarketWhisper9h ago
Bitmine gets promoted to the NYSE main board! Tom Lee: U.S. stocks may have bottomed out, and Ether’s selling pressure may ease
Bitmine has officially moved from the NYSE American board to the main board in the United States, marking an important milestone for the company. Despite a sharp drop in its stock price, it has still increased its share repurchase authorization to $4.0 billion. The company holds a large amount of Ether, and it predicts that a rebound in the crypto market will help boost its assets and stock price performance.
CryptoCity10h ago
